Hagerman’s Hills

Hagerman/East Patchogue

This morning, Robert and I embarked on a quest to locate the mythical land of Hagerman.


“We’re going to Hagerman!? Yayyy!!”

Geographic names are not limited to their assignment on maps. They are living, fluid things, often varying according to region. And sometimes they are vestigial, outliving their original function. They can linger long after they serve their purpose as official place names. Such is the case with Hagerman, a name featured prominently in East Patchogue, but lacking any designation as a Long Island village or hamlet.

Traveling east through Patchogue, Robert and I reached Swan Lake. Here, the road splits, taking drivers into scenic Bellport if they bear to the right. Robert and I chose to head left, bringing us into commercial East Patchogue. After passing rows of strip malls and industrial areas, we came upon a large sign.


Note: Not a village.

We had entered the Hagerman Fire District, yet we were in East Patchogue. How did this happen? Like a less-romantic El Dorado, the lost city of Hagerman exists only in the dusty pages of Long Island’s small history.


Frederick Dunton

The story of Hagerman is one of entrepreneurship and, ultimately, financial ruin. By the late 19th century, the Austin Corbin’s Long Island Railroad was the most efficient method of travel between Manhattan and eastern Long Island. But Corbin’s son-in-law, Frederick Dunton, saw room for improvement. He invested his fortune in a revolutionary new train called the bicycle railroad. Inventor Eben Moody Boynton saw that by laying one track on the ground and another above the train, cars could carry more weight without having to compromise their speed. Dunton formed the New York and Brooklyn Suburban Investment Company, and named George Hagerman as secretary and treasurer. 


Recognizing the competition that Dunton’s railway would bring to the Long Island Railroad, Corbin blocked his son-in-law attempts to build on his company’s land. Although the train’s test run in East Patchogue was a success, the project’s budget was $1.6 million. Dunton was unable to compete with the Corbin’s powerful and influential LIRR, and the company soon went bust.

Then what remains of Mr. Dunton’s failed dream of a “monorailroad” across Long Island?

IMG_1689         IMG_1692


Other than street names and the fire district itself, the only physical evidence remaining are a series of gently rolling hills on South Dunton Avenue. They were the raised beds that served as the right of way for the old Bicycle Railroad.


Dunton Avenue, looking south towards the bay

Luckily, our journey had thoroughly bored lulled Robert to sleep. Our quest had come to an end, and our journey into the lost land of Hagerman was now a distant memory.

IMG_1727 IMG_1704

Many thanks to the South Country Retired Educators Association for their diligent research. 


About Rob Fleming

Need to know basis, fool.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Hagerman’s Hills

  1. Carrie Ebel says:

    I always learn something new from you!!!

  2. Meredith says:

    There’s more to the story..Hagerman also made Hagerman’s Landing in Rocky Point, where he purchased a number of homes, ventured with a trolley to transport his potential clients up to the North shore to his sea side resort on the North shore too!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s